Lessons from AI-caused Marketing Missteps

As digital marketing continues to evolve, artificial intelligence (AI) has become a powerful tool in the arsenal of many companies. However, the integration of AI into marketing strategies doesn't always go smoothly. Some brands have learned this the hard way, facing backlash from consumers or missteps that could have been avoided with more careful planning and consideration. By examining these instances, companies can better understand how to use AI responsibly and effectively in their marketing efforts.

If you're considering incorporating AI into your marketing strategies, take these lessons to heart to avoid these mistakes!

Selkie Disappoints Fans

Fashion brand Selkie hoped to dazzle its followers with a 2024 Valentine’s Day collection designed using AI. The reveal on Instagram, however, quickly turned sour as users noticed oddities like a dog with too many toes in one of the designs. Despite Selkie's enthusiasm for AI, the backlash was immediate, with fans expressing disappointment that the brand chose AI over human artists.

The lesson here is clear: AI in creative domains, especially those deeply personal and expressive like fashion, can alienate consumers. While using AI might seem forward-thinking, it’s crucial to gauge consumer sentiment and involve human oversight to maintain authenticity and emotional connection with your audience.

Under Armour Doesn’t Tell the Full Story

Under Armour’s attempt to innovate with its "first AI-powered sports commercial" also encountered criticism. The brand boasted about creating the commercial with minimal human intervention, only to be corrected publicly. Creatives involved in the project highlighted their contributions, which were significant but initially unacknowledged by the brand. This oversight led to accusations of misleading marketing and disrespect toward the creators’ efforts.

This scenario underscores the importance of transparency, especially when AI tools are used to augment creative processes. It’s necessary to acknowledge the human input and respect intellectual property rights to maintain trust and integrity in marketing communications.

Read More > Digital Marketing Trends

Instacart Paints a Not-So-Pretty Picture

Instacart's use of AI-generated images and recipes in its app provided a less than appetizing experience for users. With bizarre images like conjoined cooked chickens and a hot dog with the texture of a tomato, the AI clearly needed a more refined touch. Although Instacart was transparent about using AI, the brand had to replace many images with standard stock photos after public feedback.

This incident highlights the necessity of a human review layer before AI-generated content reaches the public. Transparency about using AI is good, but ensuring the quality of the content is paramount to avoid damaging the brand’s reputation.

Dove’s Commitment to Real Beauty

Contrasting with the previous examples, Dove has taken a firm stance against using AI to replace real people in its advertising. The company introduced the Real Beauty Prompt Guidelines to help ensure AI-generated images uphold a more inclusive standard of beauty. Dove's campaign "The Code" illustrates the potential negative impacts of AI on consumer self-perception, aligning with its ongoing mission to promote real beauty.

From Dove's approach, brands can learn that aligning AI use with core company values can resonate positively with consumers. It demonstrates a commitment to authenticity and can distinguish a brand as a consumer-centric leader in ethical AI use.

While You’re Here > Why Hiring a Human Writer is Still Essential

Navigating AI in Marketing: A Strategic Approach

The lessons from these AI missteps are invaluable for any brand looking to integrate new technologies into their marketing strategies. AI offers incredible potential to save time and enhance creativity, but it also comes with pitfalls that can alienate consumers or lead to ethical dilemmas. Brands should not only keep their core values and consumer expectations in mind but also maintain a rigorous standard for transparency and quality.

If you’re unsure about integrating AI into your marketing strategies, consulting with a digital marketing agency like us at Charisma Communications that understands both the power and the pitfalls of AI can be a wise decision. With careful planning and expert guidance, you can leverage AI to enhance your marketing efforts without falling into common traps. Reach out to our team today!

‍